Dirty Dozen List 2021 - OnlyFans

The Problem

OnlyFans is the latest iteration of the online sexual exploitation marketplace.

OnlyFans makes money off of vulnerable people’s bodies – especially the bodies of women and minors. Exploiting financial insecurities deepened by the COVID-19 crisis, OnlyFans promises fast cash, empowerment, and even fame. While “Fans” may pay fees for nude images, videos, and livestreams, it is the “creators” who pay the high price of psychological, emotional, and physical harm that the sex industry imparts. As a self-branded “influencer” platform, OnlyFans also normalizes prostitution among young persons.

The site has quickly risen in public consciousness since being launched in 2016, so that as of December 2020 it was ranked the 92nd most visited site in the United States and the 170th most visited site in the world. It has been heralded by some as an empowering and safe way to sell sex—but the reality is that OnlyFans facilitates sexual exploitation, harms minors, and emboldens men to objectify and degrade women.

Help expose OnlyFans for enabling sexual exploitation by taking action below!

OnlyFans has a subscription-based business model, where a viewer pays a monthly membership fee and tips to see a “content creator’s” photos and videos. The owner, Leonid Radvinsky, reportedly has “a history of lawsuits and allegations of spam, theft, fraud, and drug dealing.” He owns other large pornography webcamming websites, and so clearly it seems that the platform’s intention is to facilitate commercial sex acts online.

The site entices new performers by claiming “You could earn between $1,499 and $7,495 per month.” Further, OnlyFans encourages grooming and pimping through its referral system which allows individuals to profit 5% of anyone’s earnings who signs up via their referral link for the first year of their account. It is no surprise that unaffiliated online pimps actively recruit new girls and women to join. One survivor of OnlyFans stated, “They usually approach the model on Twitter and groom her so that she will agree to let them help “manage” her online presence in exchange for a cut. People are desperate naive and they fall for it. This naturally creates a perfect opportunity for blackmail and other types of emotional manipulation. It happens all. the. time. And it isn’t talked about nearly enough…”

  1. Sex Trafficking and Child Sexual Exploitation: OnlyFans Does Not Adequately Verify Age or Consent

OnlyFans has insufficient verification measures for age or consent—meaning it is highly likely that child sexual abuse materials and sex trafficked persons are being exploited on the platform.  In August 2020, Forensic News conducted an investigation, reporting: “To test the privacy concerns regarding OnlyFans, Forensic News signed up for an account with OnlyFans using a throwaway email account with ProtonMail and made a post on the platform. Not once were we asked to show any identification proving that the account belonged to someone over the age of 18.” This is in line with previous reports such as by Internet Matters which stated: “In May 2019, OnlyFans introduced a new account verification process that a Creator now must provide a ‘selfie’ along with their ID in the image to prove their identity. Yet, from our research and that of the BBC’s, underage users have used other people’s ID’s and have created an account without a problem.”

It is an accepted fact, supported by survivors of sex trafficking and child abuse, that pornographic pictures and videos are used to advertise for both sex trafficking and prostitution victims (including minors.) Further, law enforcement is finding that many sex trafficking victims, and child sexual abuse imagery (i.e. child pornography) victims, are coerced into creating livestream or webcam pornography as well. OnlyFans is therefore an obvious marketplace for exploiters to promote and sell sexual abuses.

Parents are speaking out about adults buying child sexual abuse images of young girls on OnlyFans. For example, on a UK online forum one mother wrote: “My [daughter] says they’re all on it at school and making a fortune. Very popular with Y11- 13 [approximate ages 15-17]. It’s normal apparently, and kids throughout the country are doing it. She said, they tell parents they are having a bath, or just use their bedrooms.” Another mother responded to this post saying she’d discussed the issue with her own high school aged daughter and noted, “Mine says she isn’t doing it, but has close friends who are.”

Tragically, cases of people being sex trafficked for the purpose of pornographic content on OnlyFans have begun to surface as well. In Miami, a couple was arrested for human trafficking after they posted sexually explicit images of a 16-year-old on social media, promoting the images for sale as “New Content” with a link to their OnlyFans page.

  1. Online Prostitution and Pornography: Inherent Harms

While some claim OnlyFans is safe because it doesn’t require physical contact with sex buyers, it actually leaves people vulnerable to sextortion, non-consensually shared pornography, and escalation into more extreme acts.

Former OnlyFans performer, Claudia, stated, “Each subscriber paid me $10 a week and after the cut from OF [OnlyFans] I was left with £8. I needed to get as many subscribers as possible so I could pay my rent, which means posting new images all day every day, and agreeing to more and more explicit stuff. In the end I felt exhausted and degraded and cancelled my membership.”

On a UK forum, another woman wrote: “I personally know of a friend who went down that route, made a decent amount in the first few months, only to be pushed to show her face and do more and more extreme acts to retain her subscribers who all ended up leaving anyway. She has now quit but her videos are stuck on free porn sites and reposted on forums from time to time. Her case isn’t a rare one.”

Further, recently it was reported that a 21-year-old woman in Australia who posted pornography on OnlyFans was followed and harassed by a man who went on to leak her personal information online.

OnlyFans promotes itself as a safe platform, but in reality it pedals psychological trauma, blackmail, “leaked” information and videos, and a competitive marketplace that drives performers to do increasingly violent or degrading acts.

Watch This Webinar from World Without Exploitation

WARNING: Any pornographic images have been blurred, but are still suggestive. There may also be graphic text descriptions shown in these sections.
POSSIBLE TRIGGER.

Proof

OnlyFans and Prostitution - How It Harms

OnlyFans and Prostitution - How It Harms

It is an accepted fact, supported by survivor testimony, that pornographic pictures and videos are used to advertise for both sex trafficking and prostitution victims. (Law enforcement is finding that many sex trafficking victims and child sexual abuse imagery (i.e. child pornography) victims are coerced into creating live stream or webcam pornography as well.)

So it is not surprising that some individuals use OnlyFans to promote in-person prostitution.

Prostitution is a system of commercial sexual exploitation that causes psychological and physical trauma, which cannot be regulated away.

Overwhelmingly, the persons purchased for sex are women (but also include male and female children, transgendered males, and prostituting men), and those doing the purchasing are men. Without question, the vast majority of physical and sexual violence inflicted on those in the sex trade is perpetrated by those purchasing persons for sex—the sex buyers.

For Example:

In interviews with women in prostitution in Canada, more than 50% of the women reported experiencing violence from sexual buyers, including being: stabbed or cut, raped, gang-raped, raped at gunpoint, forced to engage in degrading sexual acts, choked/strangled, beaten, kidnapped, stalked, held with a gun to head, tied up, tortured, beaten with objects (e.g. baseball bat, crowbar), and run over. (1)

A study in San Francisco interviewed 130 prostituting persons (women, men, and transgender men, aged 14-61) regarding violence in their lives and symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Types and amounts of violence experienced while in prostitution included: 82% were physically assaulted; 55% of physical assaults were perpetrated by sex buyers. (2)

A study of street-based prostitution in inner-city Washington, D.C., found high incidents of violence. Since entering prostitution, 61% reported being physically assaulted, with the majority being perpetrated by sexual buyers (75%). And 76.2% wanted to exit prostitution but didn't feel like it was viable. (3)

READ MORE RESEARCH HERE


(1) Nixon, K., Tutty, L., Downe, P., Gorkoff, K., & Ursel, J. (2002, September). The everyday occurrence: Violence in the lives of girls exploited through prostitution. Violence Against Women, 8(9), 1016-1043.

(2) Farley, M. and Barkan, H. (1998). Prostitution, violence against women, and posttraumatic stress disorder. Women & Health, 27(3), 37-49.

(3) Valera, R., Sawyer, R. & Schiraldi, G. (2001). Perceived health needs of inner-city street prostitutes: A preliminary study American Journal Health Behavior, 25(1), 50-59.

Examples of Sex Trafficking, Pimps, and Children on OnlyFans

Examples of Sex Trafficking, Pimps, and Children on OnlyFans

Children on OnlyFans

Numerous recent news stories have highlighted cases of minors creating and selling sexually explicit content of themselves on OnlyFans. The Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM, the more apt term for child pornography) found on OnlyFans also includes instances where children are exploited by traffickers. OnlyFans’ Age Verification systems have failed to detect and prevent these cases of CSAM. What’s more, their marketing strategies and attempts to normalize the commercial sex industry are contributing to the allure children feel towards webcamming through OnlyFans.

A May 2021 piece by BBC, The children selling explicit videos on OnlyFans, offered a thorough investigation into minors creating and selling self-generated child sex abuse material on OnlyFans. Through the numerous cases described, a common theme emerges: these children are enticed by the promise of easy money, as well as the hope of growing in popularity and social influence. As one 13-year-old says: "I know it's not appropriate for kids my age to be doing this, but it's an easy way to make money. . . Some of the girls have thousands of followers on Instagram and they must be raking it in - I wanna be just like them." Another 16-year-old bragged to her school career advisor about the money she was making through OnlyFans, asking why she should listen to any career advice from her.

Posts on an online forum for mothers noting underage teenagers using OnlyFans:

Child Sex Trafficking on OnlyFans

While much of the CSAM on OnlyFans is a product of minors uploading their own self-produced content, police and child protection agencies are also uncovering cases of children being trafficked or exploited on the platform. For example, the Vice President of the National Centre on Missing and Exploited Children, Staca Shehan, states: “In 2019 there were around a dozen children known to be missing being linked with content on OnlyFans. Last year the number of those cases nearly tripled.” Police forces have also received complaints from children who had others upload intimate images of them to OnlyFans without their consent. In another case, a minor had her face edited onto someone else’s body, and the resulting pornographic content uploaded to OnlyFans. Yet another minor complained to the police that she was blackmailed into posting images on OnlyFans.

Pimps/Traffickers using OnlyFans

Tragically, cases of people being sex trafficked for the purpose of pornographic content on OnlyFans have begun to surface as well. In Miami, a couple was arrested for human trafficking after they posted sexually explicit images of a 16-year-old on social media, promoting the images for sale as “New Content” with a link to their OnlyFans page. We know where prostitution occurs, sex trafficking soon follows.

Furthermore, OnlyFans offers a 5% “cut” of a creator’s first year earnings to a “Referrer, creating an avenue for even more profit by enterprising pimps and traffickers and incentivizing exploiters to recruit “creators.”

A survivor of OnlyFans has publicly noted: "There are tons of "promoters" and "managers" (online pimps) who actively prey upon new girls (the younger the better). They usually approach the model on Twitter and groom her so that she will agree to let them help "manage" her online presence in exchange for a cut. People are desperate naive and they fall for it. This naturally creates a perfect opportunity for blackmail and other types of emotional manipulation. It happens all. the. time...As seems to be the case across the adult industry, OnlyFans creators by-and-large claim to love what they do. I have no doubt that this is true in many cases. But I also have no doubt that many creators are just saying that because they have to in order to retain their subscribers. " (see full text below)

Recently. it was reported that a 21-year-old woman in Australia who posted pornography on OnlyFans was followed and harassed by a man who went on to leak her personal information online.

*The following is from a Subreddit posted in early 2021:

Verified!

I was an OnlyFans model for six months. It made me realize that I'm anti-sex work.

Discussion

This is gonna be really long, but it's something that I've wanted to get off my chest for a while now, and this sub seems like a good place to do so.

A little bit about me for context: I'm a 21-year-old female college student who has always enjoyed a safe, comfortable life. I had a pleasant middle-class upbringing. I have good friends and a wonderful boyfriend. My choice to create an OnlyFans was not out of necessity, but mostly out of curiosity and a desire to make a little extra cash during Covid so I could pay off some bills and save enough to move out of my parents' house. My circumstances aren't very unique in that a lot of girls with backgrounds similar to mine seem to be dabbling in online sex work, particularly on OnlyFans.

Anyway, I created my account this past February. Got active during March at the beginning of lockdown. I was staying with my boyfriend at the time and he was very supportive of it, basically had a "get your bag" attitude and thought it was funny that guys would pay $6 a month to view my nudes and talk to me. My content was very softcore for the most part. I did end up doing some more explicit videos that I'd sell as 'pay-per-view' (PPV) messages, and I had some money shots in there. But in the greater scheme of things, it was all pretty tame. I showed my face. I wasn't totally worried about the long-term consequences of my nudes being online forever (which, spoiler alert, they are - everything on OnlyFans gets leaked), mostly because this type of thing has been fairly "normalized" (gross, I know) and I knew for a fact that they would never affect my career prospects based on what I want to do.

Things were slow in the beginning. I made $60 my first month. It was whatever, but I was determined to earn more. I'm fairly attractive and have kind of a nerdy look, and I'm very natural on camera (my feed consisted mostly of pictures but I made some videos of me doing mundane shit in lingerie while talking to the camera, which my small audience dug).

Gradually, my account grew in popularity. From the compliments to the cash, I was loving it. I made $300 the next month. $1000 after that. Then $1500. At my peak, I earned $2500 in a month. I had enough to move into my own place (my parents assumed the money was coming from other jobs that I had been doing on the side, which wasn't entirely false). It was great.

But eventually, the hype wore off. I hated making content in the thick summer heat. I started to get migraines from looking at a screen for hours on end (2/3 of the job consisted of promoting on Twitter and Reddit). I started to hate the attention; it made me sort of narcissistic and hyper-aware of my appearance at all times, which had never been typical for me. I hated that I had an obligation to be posting and networking with other creators constantly. I got tired of reading all the creepy DMs from both randos on Twitter and paying subscribers. The worst part, though, was that I could no longer look at my naked body in the mirror without thinking about it as something to be consumed by other people, even if only in photographs and videos. I felt alienated from my own sexuality. It was draining. I felt gross. I wasn't happy.

After a few mental breakdowns and several long discussions with my boyfriend, I realized I had to quit. And I was so happy when I did.

In the months since then, I've reconnected with my body and sexuality and become staunchly anti-sex work and anti-porn. I have nothing against sex workers themselves, but I don't think sex work of any kind (online or in-person) would exist as we know it without economic precarity. Because it does exist on such a massive scale, though, there's this narrative that we should support and defend sex work at all costs. It's bullshit. People like to talk about OnlyFans as if it's this ethical alternative to free porn sites (i.e. Pornhub) when the reality is that so many things about it are fundamentally the same. Sure, creators are (ostensibly) working independently and not under the discretion of predatory producers and contracts (though this is not entirely true). Sure, it does not host a plethora of readily-available rape and child abuse videos. But there's still a lot of sketchy shit going on. Here are a few examples:

  • There are no real safeguards in place to ensure that all models are of age.
    • I'm sorry, but a single ID picture doesn't cut it. IDs can be convincingly altered with fucking Facetune. Plus, even if an adult signs up with a valid ID, they can upload all sorts of content featuring other people who are not age verified on the platform. I have no doubt that there's a decent amount of CP on OnlyFans.
  • There are tons of "promoters" and "managers" (online pimps) who actively prey upon new girls (the younger the better).
    • They usually approach the model on Twitter and groom her so that she will agree to let them help "manage" her online presence in exchange for a cut. People are desperate naive and they fall for it. This naturally creates a perfect opportunity for blackmail and other types of emotional manipulation. It happens all. the. time. And it isn't talked about nearly enough in the online sex work community.
  • There are tons of models peddling the idea that it's "empowering" and should be "normalized".
    • To their credit, many OnlyFans models have spoken out against this notion, but there are toooons of them who talk like this. There is nothing empowering about showing your body to people for money. It's a job, for Christ's sake - it's no more empowering than working at a grocery store. And the idea that it should be normalized because "sex work is work!" is beyond harmful. Online sex work is no joke. It can have all sorts of serious consequences, ranging from reputation damage to doxxing and stalking to general trauma caused by any number of factors. It is absolutely fucking insane to think that 18-year-olds are allowed to consent to this.
  • It encourages the societal grooming of underage girls.
    • I have seen SO many 16, 17-year-old girls on Twitter and TikTok talking about how they "can't wait until they turn 18" to create an OnlyFans. It's really depressing, but far more disturbing is the fact that you look at their replies and see a ton of adults encouraging them to do so because, again, "sex work is work!". It's fucking sick.

As seems to be the case across the adult industry, OnlyFans creators by-and-large claim to love what they do. I have no doubt that this is true in many cases. But I also have no doubt that many creators are just saying that because they have to in order to retain their subscribers.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that I really really really hate the casual enthusiasm surrounding OnlyFans and sex work discourse as a whole. The appeal of the "do-it-yourself" approach to porn (or lingerie pictures, or whatever) overshadows the dark reality of sex work that many women encounter through these types of platforms.

I'm anti-sex work because I think that the vast majority of sex work is inherently exploitative. For every woman funding her dream life on OnlyFans, there are thousands on the platform who struggle to make ends meet, who do it to cope with trauma, who dabble in it without recognizing the long-term consequences of having their intimate photos online forever. "Ethical porn" will always exist in the same sphere as "unethical porn". Predators will always try to take advantage of new/young/naive models and performers, and experienced and successful creators will not use their platforms to speak out against it because they're so far removed from it. It's all a load of garbage, and I can't wait for everyone else to realize that.

Left with Little Money, Pushed to Degrading Acts, Exposed to Risks

Promotional Posts Showing OnlyFans Sells Pornography

“Content Creators” Left with Little Money, Pushed to Perform Degrading Acts, and Exposed to Threats and Stalking 

Many of the “content creators” on OnlyFans are those struggling to make ends meet, worrying about paying bills and being able to feed their families. This has been exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic with millions of people out of work and without income. To make matters worse, the majority of those creating content for OnlyFans have trouble making anywhere near enough money to survive, despite putting in hours of work every day. Additionally, OnlyFans takes a 20% cut of “creator” earnings, and creators must make $200 before they’re able to withdraw any of the money. Despite all of this effort put in and minimal return, “creators” are repeatedly put at risk. 

Jobless, Selling Nudes Online and Still Struggling (New York Times: January 13, 2021) 

The pandemic has taken a particularly devastating toll on women and mothers, wiping out parts of the economy where women dominate: retail businesses, restaurants and health care. 

“A lot of people are migrating to OnlyFans out of desperation,” said Angela Jones, an associate professor of sociology at the State University of New York at Farmingdale. “These are people who are worried about eating, they’re worried about keeping the lights on, they’re worried about not being evicted.” 

The most successful content creators are often models, porn stars and celebrities who already have large social media followings. 

...

Creators can also be subject to “capping,” a practice in which users take unauthorized screenshots or recordings and then share them elsewhere on the internet. OnlyFans creators have also received death and rape threats on social media. 

Hialeah Couple Hit With Human Trafficking Charges (CBSMiami.com, January 29, 2021) 

A couple from Hialeah is facing human trafficking charges after posting and selling a video of a topless underage teen on a social media website known for selling pornography. 

Roberto Cuesta, 27, and Julietta Vado, 23, have been charged with human trafficking for commercial purposes, possession of a sexual performance by a child, and promoting the sexual performance by a child. 

According to police, a friend of the 16-year-old recognized her from a video that was posted on the couple’s page on the website and contacted the state’s Department of Children and Families. 

Police say Cuesta and Vado are live-in boyfriend and girlfriend who sell their self-produced pornography on their OnlyFans page.  

Vado reportedly posted the video of the teen on her social media site and promoted it for sale with the caption ” New Content” with a link to their OnlyFans page.  

When the DCF notified them that the teen was a minor, they failed to remove the video and continued to promote it for sale, according to the arrest report. 

Only Fans Faces Allegations of Fraud, Theft 

. . .an analysis by Forensic News has revealed that OnlyFans is owned by a Ukrainian-American porn entrepreneur named Leonid Radvinsky with a history of lawsuits and allegations of spam, theft, fraud, and drug dealing. 

Other concerns include the uber-popular OnlyFans’ seemingly lax safeguards against possible child exploitation. 

One recurring complaint that Forensic News documented by talking to various users and content creators of both [Radvinsky owned] MyFreeCams and OnlyFans was the arbitrary freezing of accounts, which left many without thousands of dollars.  

One day I had enough [of bad customer support] and told my fans not to tip for a day. Many models were going to join me. Then my account was banned in minutes,” the model who spoke on condition of anonymity said. 

There’s nothing ‘empowering’ about the sex work on OnlyFans (The Spectator, April 2020) 

‘Each subscriber paid me $10 a week and after the cut from OF I was left with £8. I needed to get as many subscribers as possible so I could pay my rent, which means posting new images all day every day,’ says [Name Redacted], ‘and agreeing to more and more explicit stuff. In the end I felt exhausted and degraded and cancelled my membership.’ 

Then there is the girlfriend experience. OF offers men the opportunity to pay providers for a day, or however long, to behave as if they are a real date, and via messages and voice notes send instructions as to what he requires of his ‘girlfriend’. 

It’s not surprising that this leads to reports of subscribers becoming obsessed with and going on to stalk the women they follow on OF. Last month it was reported that a 21-year-old woman in Australia who posted explicit content on OF was followed and harassed by a man who went on to leak her personal information online. 

I heard from another woman about being sexually harassed by a subscriber after she rejected his pleas to meet up in real life. ‘He ended up tracking down my real name and mobile number,’ she told me, ‘and put up a fake advert… on a porn site.’ The young woman was soon deluged with dozens of calls and messages from men before she was forced to change her number. 

How OnlyFans became the industry’s great lockdown winner – and at what cost (New Statesman: November 4, 2020) 

Every now and again, a tweet by a previously unknown OnlyFans creator will go viral, as she (always she) shares photos of the house she has been able to buy “thanks to OnlyFans”. But as the blogger Thomas Hollands has found in his detailed analysis of the OnlyFans model, such rags-to-riches cases are unusual. According to Hollands’s interpretation of the data, most of the women on the platform probably make a loss, given the amount of time they spend creating content and engaging with users. The median creator attracts only 30 subscribers, but she carries just as much risk of public exposure and harassment as her more successful counterparts. The same amount of effort goes in, but a very different level of reward comes out. 

The distribution of income on OnlyFans is highly unequal, with the top 1 per cent of creators making 33 per cent of the money. Using the Gini index – a standard measure of economic inequality – Hollands finds OnlyFans to be more unequal than South Africa, the most unequal country in the world. The tiny minority of creators who do well on the platform are mostly celebrities already, meaning the women who post “thanks to OnlyFans” success stories on social media are not representative of ordinary creators, but are rather more like those rare punters who walk out of a casino as millionaires, having put it all on red. 

‘Everyone and their mum is on it’: OnlyFans booms in popularity during the pandemic (The Guardian, December 2020) 

This time last year [Name Redacted] was doing it tough. She had fled an abusive relationship, was looking after her newborn daughter and was struggling to find work in far north Queensland. 

“Every single regular job that I had, I was getting sexually harassed in some way,” she says. “I would either get fired or I’d have to leave once I reported it.” 

When the pandemic hit all remaining gigs dried up. 

“I was like, ‘OK. Why not make money out of this [OnlyFans] and have control over my body?’” 

[Name Redacted] says the site recently reduced the minimum amount of earnings it will pay from $500 to $200 because many users struggled to reach the threshold. 

[Name Redacted] says users who fail to establish a wide fanbase may work for many months, or even years, without receiving significant payment. 

“In reality, it is often small amounts that trickle in over time, many of which become diluted through commissions and international transfer fees,” she says. 

According to content creator [Name Redacted] it took months of working almost for free before she began making real money. 

“It was about a year before I really started seeing any type of income and even then it’s not like a steady income or anything,” she says. “I can have some days where [I] only make maybe $10, and then [I] can have weeks where [I’ve] actually cashed in about $500. 

Take Action

Tell New US Attorney General at DOJ to Investigate Only Fans!

Sign This Petition

Demand OnlyFans take measures to prevent child sexual exploitation!

Tell Credit Cards to Stop Processing Payments for OnlyFans