January 9, 2019

WhatsApp Has A Child Pornography Problem

First it was Tumblr, now it’s WhatsApp.

Last November, it was discovered that child sexual abuse images (i.e. child pornography) was being shared on the popular social media platform Tumblr. As a result, Apple removed the Tumblr app from their App Store.

In December, Tumblr decided the only way to truly correct this issue was to remove all pornographic content from their platform.

Now, WhatsApp is facing the same problem. WhatsApp, owned by Facebook, is one of the most popular messaging apps in the world. Early last year, WhatsApp hit 1.5 billion monthly users with over 60 billion messages sent per day.

It was recently discovered that some WhatsApp users were creating group chats to share child sexual abuse images (child pornography). While these groups aren’t searchable natively within the app, multiple third-party apps were created to discover and provide links to join groups. Over 130,000 accounts have already been banned for participating in these groups.

There are two major factors that contribute to this issue:

1. WhatsApp allows adult pornography on their platform.

While child pornography is banned on WhatsApp, adult pornography is allowed. As Tumblr learned first-hand, permitting adult pornography opens the door for a toxic environment. Boundaries are slowly pushed and content becomes gradually more extreme.

Now, obviously, age is the key element here. However, we know from testimonies of former prosecutors of child pornography that the downward spiral into viewing more extreme content, such as child pornography, sometimes starts with “regular” adult pornography. This is due to the need for escalation… As platforms become a gathering place for consumers of pornography to share content, it is not a surprise that child pornography would eventually show up.

2. WhatsApp lacks proper moderation.

Facebook has a team of 20,000 employees monitoring content posted on the platform. However, none of these employees work for the Facebook-owned WhatsApp. Instead, WhatsApp, with just 300 employees, handles all of its own moderation separately. How could just 300 employees monitor 60 billion messages each day? The answer is they can’t. And, as many platforms have learned, relying on automated moderation simply isn’t enough.

It’s time for WhatsApp to follow Tumblr’s example and remove all adult content from the platform. Until they do, it is impossible to imagine a foreseeable future in which the issue of child pornography goes away.

Ben Miller

Former Digital Strategies Coordinator

Ben joined the National Center on Sexual Exploitation as Digital Strategies Coordinator in July of 2018. As Digital Strategies Coordinator, Ben raises awareness for issues of sexual exploitation through digital media, email marketing, and website development. He works to create a community of activists who are enthusiastic about combating sexual exploitation and changing culture.

Ben earned his Bachelor of Arts from the University of Wisconsin – Madison. He graduated with Honors in the Liberal Arts and was elected to Phi Beta Kappa. During his college career, Ben spent a semester studying in Washington, D.C. and interned for a member of Congress. On campus, he actively sought to change Greek culture, especially with respect to sexual exploitation, through his membership in Phi Kappa Theta fraternity. Ben also supported his peers who were afflicted by the harms of pornography through a weekly men’s purity group.

Ben’s deep commitment to fighting sexual exploitation was ignited in part by the work done by NCOSE. While writing a research literature review for a public policy class in college, he came across Porn Harms Research and the initiatives being carried out by NCOSE. Ben, a strong anti-pornography activist at the time, began to learn more about the connections between all forms of exploitation and how prominent these issues are in today’s society. He devoted himself to raising awareness about the web of sexual exploitation and is deeply grateful for the work NCOSE has done on these issues. Ben is excited to be a part of the team at the National Center on Sexual Exploitation and to contribute to this important cause.

Further Reading